Challenging “Hate the Sin, Love the Sinner”

Is it possible to love someone while hating their behavior or decisions? In this episode of Life Repurposed, host Michelle Rayburn explores the potentially controversial phrase "hate the sin, love the sinner," challenging its implications and impact on our relationships. Through biblical insights and compelling examples, Michelle discusses the potential harm and judgmental attitudes this phrase may foster, advocating for a more empathetic and inclusive approach to loving others. She’s honest and transparent about her own thoughts on how to treat others and the origin of the phrase. Listen in and explore the transformative power of genuine love and acceptance.

Listen on Podbean or play below


Michelle Rayburn is an author and podcast host who helps others find hope in the trashy stuff of life. She has an MA in ministry leadership and writes Christian living books, humor, and Bible studies. Together with her husband, they've raised two sons and gained two daughters-in-law—plus three granddaughters (go estrogen team!) and a grandson. Dark chocolate, an iced coffee, and a good book in the hammock top Michelle's favorites list.

Key Ideas

  • Introduction to the topic of loving others.
  • Discussing Jesus's teachings on loving your neighbor, including Christian brothers/sisters and those living in what might be considered a sinful lifestyle
  • Exploring the concept of showing unconditional love, mercy, and grace

How This Looks in Practice

  • Michelle's thoughts on the idea that it's not loving to allow someone to remain stuck in sin
  • Highlighting how this selective viewpoint requires individuals to sit in God's place, put conditions on others, and lacks clear guidelines

Jesus's Approach

  • Examining the story of Zacchaeus from the New Testament and Jesus's love and compassion for those marginalized or considered sinners by society
  • Discussing how Jesus's approach led to Zacchaeus' transformation and repentance
  • How Jesus focused on accepting and initiating contact with the marginalized, leading to transformation through love and grace
  • Noting the contrast between individuals zealously following rules and lacking compassion, and Jesus's approach to people's needs

Love Versus Hate

  • Reflecting on the impact of hate and how it can lead to destructive behaviors and have detrimental effects on mental health
  • Highlighting the difference between disagreement and hate, and how hate escalates conflicts, hindering productive dialogue and collaboration
  • Discussing the importance of practicing love without judgment or condemnation, and building authentic relationships
  • Emphasizing the importance of creating welcoming and accepting environments in homes and workplaces, regardless of people's beliefs, background, or lifestyle
  • Advocating for engaging in respectful dialogue instead of debating, approaching conversations with openness, humility, and seeking to understand others
  • Emphasizing the importance of offering support, encouragement, guidance, and asking individuals what they need for personal and spiritual growth
  • Discussing the role of the Holy Spirit in transforming people's lives and the importance of leaving space for this transformation to occur

Next Steps

  • Challenging the execution of "hate the sin, love the sinner," and its potential for judgment, exclusion, and harm
  • Advocating for seeking truth, spreading love, and challenging the status quo as a means to see transformation in our lives
  • Exploring the need to question and reevaluate beliefs and ideals in midlife
  • Discussing the complexities and potential harm of the expression and encouraging listeners to critically evaluate its implications in their interactions with others

Other episodes to check out:

Episode 33: Has Fear Replaced Our Love?


Life Repurposed Substack Magazine and Bonuses

Life Repurposed is where midlife meets inspiration, practical guidance, and renewed purpose amid life’s evolving chapters. We navigate faith questions and messy, uncertain twists with humor and a commitment to pursue treasure, even in the trashy stuff.

Sign up for the free magazine, emails about new podcast episodes, and community connection. Plus, there's an opportunity to subscribe to bonus content.

This post contains affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, if you click through and make a purchase, I may receive a commission. I sell my books via Amazon but I’m also a part of their “Associates” (i.e. affiliate) program which pays a commission on books and any other Amazon products people purchase via my links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Content copyright

Support the Show


Are you a podcaster? Castmagic has increased my productivity via the use of AI to repurpose my long-form show audio into ready-to-use content assets, instantly. Upload your Mp3, download transcripts, notes, summaries, highlights, and more.



Posted in Articles, Books & Resources, Podcast Episodes.